Aftershave - Bay Rum


Aftershave - Bay Rum


The one that started it all.

Proudly handcrafted in America.

SHIPPING RESTRICTIONS: Please note that shipping regulations limit aftershave sales to the continental United States.

Add To Cart

Captain's Choice Bay Rum aftershave delivers an authentic scent that customers just can't get enough of.  The wonderful bay scent predominates with hints of cinnamon and citrus.  Our Bay Rum aftershave brings just the right "zing" to a freshly shaven face and envelopes you in its heavenly scent.  Breathe deep and savor the moment... You will not only love the aroma but it will leave your face dependably moisturized all day long.  

Made with all natural ingredients and packaged in a four-ounce amber glass bottle.

Ingredients: Alcohol, witch hazel, essential oils and extracts, glycerin.

Recommended Pairings: Bay Rum Shave Balm, Bay Rum Shaving Cream, Bay Rum Shaving Soap

Feedback from our customers:


Captain’s Choice is far and away the best bay rum on the market.  The scent is addicting and the face healing qualities give it a value without equal!  This one gets six stars out of a possible five!!

- John, North Carolina


I got a sample and then bought the big bottle right away.  It is refreshing and masculine with an authentic bay rum scent.  It leaves the skin feeling good, smells great and my wife likes the way it smells.

- Frank, Connecticut


Captain's Choice gives a nice alcohol bite, smells awesome, and is crisp and clean.  Plus it gives off a slight "warming" for a short time after application. It’s gentle and I actually think that it has a therapeutic effect that helps reduce shaving irritation. Its scent has decent staying power too.  I don’t shave without it!

- Doug, Florida


I’ve been a bay rum freak for over 20 years and Captain’s Choice is the best I’ve ever tried.  It smells great and my girlfriend loves it too!!

- Ajax, New York